Ice Cream Cakes

Ways to Order

Cakes are most commonly special ordered, some may be available for sale in the front display freezer and will be listed below when applicable.  

We currently do not have a cake ready for pickup.

Since there are many options for an ice cream cake all will need to be pre-ordered and prepaid 1 week in advance to ensure it will be ready for the day you need it.   The easiest way to pre-order is by coming in person with an idea in mind; the other option is to call or email.

The options that make each ice cream cake special are:  the 2 flavors of ice cream, crunchy middle option, and the frosting.  Please know all of your choices, questions, or concerns when ordering your custom cake. 


Pricing is $40 unless otherwise specified at the time you order. 

The Options

Ice Cream Flavors

Crunchy Options

Frosting Flavors

Pick any 2 flavors and we will make accommodations to ensure your cake is ready.

Some flavors may not be available including alcoholic flavors and other soft flavors.

  • Oreos

  • Chocolate Crunchies

  • M & M s

  • Reese's Pieces

  • Brownies

  • Chocolate Covered            Espresso Beans

  • Chocolate Covered            Pretzels

  • Reese's PB Cups

  • Nuts 

  • Graham Cracker Crust

Both vanilla and chocolate frostings are available and if left unspecified we will default to the best frosting.  Writing on the cakes is possible if desired when preordering. 

Currently Unavailable

We are only doing curbside Pick Up Until Further Notice



960 East Warner Rd.



AZ 85225


Tel: 480-292-7255




Sun  1pm-9pm

Mon 2:30pm-9pm

Tues Closed

Wed 2:30pm-9pm

Thur 2:30pm-9pm

Fri   2:30pm-9pm

Sat  1pm-9pm


©2019 McMahon's Ice Cream