Ice Cream Pies

Ways to Order an Ice Cream Pie

You can choose any available ice cream for a custom pie made to order today.  For best selection, give us three days notice.  Each month 2-3 pies are chosen as the pies of the month and will be displayed in the front freezer while supplies last.  Pies that are available in the front freezer may also be sold as $3 slices periodically. We offer two sizes of pies; Oreo Crust Pies (8") and Graham Cracker Crust Pies (10") and either can be filled with any of our flavors.  Pies cost $15.95 but may go on sale when pre-ordering before holidays.

This Months Pies:

Key Lime 

Java Jolt

Currently Unavailable

We are only doing curbside Pick Up Until Further Notice



960 East Warner Rd.



AZ 85225


Tel: 480-292-7255




Sun  1pm-9pm

Mon 2:30pm-9pm

Tues Closed

Wed 2:30pm-9pm

Thur 2:30pm-9pm

Fri   2:30pm-9pm

Sat  1pm-9pm


©2019 McMahon's Ice Cream